After the wave: the conversation we gave up on
The wave came and went. However it broke in your district, by the following Monday the yard signs were gone, and our churches looked just as they had before. Not because nothing happened, but because most of it remained unspoken.
I’m not going to write about which party won or whether the wave was as blue as the headlines claimed. For a pastor, the more useful question is what this season stirred up in the quiet of our homes and congregations, and why so much of it went unsaid. In many of our families, it always does.
The table went quiet, and not last month
The silence in our churches around public questions is nothing new, and it is not primarily a reaction to this election. In many Chinese immigrant families, it took hold years ago, sometimes decades ago.
Immigration policy. Affirmative action. Racial justice. The EEOC and fairness in hiring. Gender and sexuality. These are not gaps in a family's memory. They are subjects that a generation of parents and grandparents deliberately chose not to debate with their adult children and grandchildren. Their reasoning was rarely foolish: the arguments seemed to lead nowhere, and they threatened a harmony that had taken a great deal to build. So the family agreed, without ever saying so, to leave those subjects alone.
It would be easy to tell a story in which the older generation is simply afraid, and the younger generation is simply right. But what I am describing is not cowardice. It is a truce, and truces are made by people who have seen what open conflict can cost.
But a truce carries a price its makers may not have anticipated. When a family stops discussing the questions that shape its members' working lives, churches, children's schools, and futures, silence does not preserve the relationship. It hollows it out. The grandmother and granddaughter still love each other. They have simply stopped knowing each other on the subjects once carried across a dinner table.
The truce made sense. That is why it held.
Before judging the truce, we need to understand it. Many parents and grandparents in our churches remember governments unlike the American one: upheaval, coercion, and public squares that turned against people like them. For some, disagreement itself was dangerous; for others, church had become the one place where they expected to find non-conflict/peace. And this caution is not uniform. Our families came from the mainland, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Southeast Asia, and their relationships with government and public disagreement differ. Fenggang Yang's "adhesive identity" describes churches where Christian, Chinese, and American identities are negotiated together rather than stacked (Yang, 1999). Protecting the family's peace was a strategy that had worked.
But it could not last. A truce can hold a family together for a generation, but it cannot pass a faith on to the next. A conviction never tested in the open becomes a default, and defaults do not survive in a world that asks the grandchildren every day what they actually believe.
The silence is not one-directional
The younger generation hears the truce as stubbornness, while the older generation hears the silence as respect. Neither interpretation tells the whole story. Research on political socialization finds that when children initiate discussions, parents may increase their news use, knowledge, and opinion formation, showing that civic learning does not flow only from parent to child (McDevitt & Chaffee, 2002). In a study of 545 Chinese immigrants reporting on 869 older parents, greater acculturation predicted more conflict over values and the relationship itself, while a stronger sense of filial obligation predicted less (Guo et al., 2022). Nor is the older generation's reserve simply an "immigrant mindset": Janelle Wong's research attributes low civic participation in substantial part to institutions that fail to mobilize immigrant communities (Wong, 2006; Wong et al., 2011). The lesson is not that respect is the problem, but that respect and adult moral agency must be held together: "I honor what you lived through, and I need you to hear what I am facing now."
The church is already a body politic
John Howard Yoder's Body Politics begins with a distinction I have never been able to unhear: the church is itself a polity, and its ordinary practices are its politics, enacted "before the watching world.”
The difference between church and state or between a faithful and an unfaithful church is not that one is political and the other not, but that they are political in different ways. (Yoder, 1992)
So "we don't do politics here" describes not something we avoided, but a distinction we never quite made. Every church I have served was already a body politic. We use one word for four different things: campaigning for a candidate; judging a law or policy; sharing a neighborhood's common life; ordering power, rights, and duties. And then flinch at all four at once. A church can refuse the first without refusing the rest. And Chinese church piety often runs two biblical categories together: being salt and light in the world and loving the world. Both use 世界 (world), one a mandate and the other a warning. When they blur, withdrawal feels like holiness.
What the numbers actually say
Public concern about political churches is real and bipartisan. In Pew's September 2022 survey, 77% of U.S. adults said churches should not endorse political candidates. About two-thirds said churches should stay out of politics altogether, while 31% said churches should express views on everyday social and political issues (Pew Research Center, 2025).
In its reporting on Asian American evangelicals ahead of the last election, the Associated Press quoted Raymond Chang of the Asian American Christian Collaborative: "We're often quiet from the pulpit and the pews when it comes to politics. We don't see much civic engagement beyond voting, but we do vote" (Bharath, 2024). If that sentence describes your church, it describes mine.
Asian American evangelicals are not a political monolith. In Pew's 2022–23 survey of 7,006 Asian American adults, 62% identified with or leaned toward the Democratic Party. The figure was 52% among Asian American Christians and 39% among Asian American evangelicals (Pew Research Center, 2023). The share of Asian Americans identifying as Christian fell from 42% in 2012 to 34% in 2023, and 56% of Chinese Americans now claim no religion. Janelle Wong adds that immigrant evangelicals are neither "natural Republicans" nor "natural Democrats" (Wong, 2018).
An apparently united family almost certainly holds sharply different convictions, and silence is not evidence of consensus. One caution: I could not find a national figure for how many Chinese families avoid these conversations, and I will not invent one.
Can a 1.5-generation pastor help?
This is the question I actually get, usually indirectly: can someone like me, a 1.5-generation pastor caught between an older, immigrant-led congregation and its English-speaking adult children, do anything about a silence that predates my ministry? I think the answer is a qualified yes, and that qualification matters.
No younger pastor can make a parent and grandchild agree, and none should try. What a 1.5-generation pastor can do is create space for the conversation a family has given up on, without anyone having to lose. We belong to both worlds: the older generation will take our calls, and the younger generation will tell us the truth. That dual standing is an asset, and almost no one else in the family has it.
The temptation is to do the opposite, and I’ve done both. One option is to quietly take the younger generation's side and call it courage. The other is to protect the older generation's peace by keeping the subject off the agenda and call it wisdom. Neither heals anything, because both make the pastor one more participant in the family's argument. Reconciliation needs someone who isn’t trying to win.
Face is not the enemy. Humiliation is.
Conflict in our churches quickly becomes a matter of face: dignity, standing, and fear of public embarrassment. We should stop treating face as a specifically Chinese flaw.
Face-negotiation research distinguishes concern for one's own face, another person's face, and the shared face of a relationship. A study of 768 participants in China, Germany, Japan, and the United States found that concern for another person's face predicted not only avoidance but also integrative, problem-solving approaches (Oetzel & Ting-Toomey, 2003). Concern for dignity can shut down a conversation. It can also make a difficult conversation possible when humiliation would otherwise have ended it.
Eric Law's The Wolf Shall Dwell with the Lamb puts this into practice. His "Mutual Invitation" begins with a leader sharing, then inviting one specific person by name; that person invites the next, and each is free to pass. Default ways of running a room are not culturally neutral: they reward the loudest and most senior voice. A younger pastor might therefore say privately: "Could we build one evening where we look at one subject together, without anyone having to convert anyone else?" A grandparent might respond not with "you'll understand when you are older" but with: "My experience leads me elsewhere. Before I explain, tell me what you think I am missing."
The avoidance is a failure of nerve
The avoidance itself is the deeper problem, and family-systems writer Edwin Friedman is unsentimental about it. A Failure of Nerve argues that when a system cannot tolerate conflict, its leader tends to become a "peace-monger,” one who "treats conflict or anxiety like mustard gas." Such leaders are often nice, and that very niceness deprives the system of the stands it needs.
Friedman's alternative is the well-differentiated leader: someone "who can be separate while still remaining connected," and "can take stands at the risk of displeasing" (Friedman, 2007). He writes about families and institutions, not churches, but I recognize the figure. I have been the pastor who kept the peace by changing the subject, and I did not lose a single member. I lost something harder to name.
Organizational research gives this failure a second name. "Psychological safety" is the shared belief that one can challenge an assumption without unacceptable cost (Edmondson, 1999; Edmondson & Lei, 2014), while "organizational silence" is what builds up when speaking feels futile (Morrison & Milliken, 2000). The studies focus on workplaces, but their questions apply here, too. Can a member disagree with a senior leader without losing a ministry role? Can a grandchild raise a public question without being told he has betrayed the family? "Everyone is welcome to speak" means little if everyone already knows which answers carry consequences. A family may think it has avoided division when, in fact, it has taught its people not to speak. That is not unity. It is quiet.
Reconciliation is not the same as agreement
Reconciliation is a word we use loosely. In Scripture, it does not mean erasing differences; it means restoring relationships across them. "God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself," Paul writes, and then entrusts the church with “the ministry of reconciliation" (2 Cor. 5:18–19). Ephesians describes Christ breaking down "the dividing wall of hostility" to create one new humanity (Eph. 2:14–16). Neither passage promises agreement. Both promise that the wall can come down without either side disappearing.
Ephraim Radner raises the stakes further: division in the body of Christ is not a neutral administrative fact but a wound, healed only through costly self-giving rather than procedural consensus (Radner, 2012). If that is true of denominations, it is true of a family, too. And the unity described in the New Testament is never sameness. In 1 Corinthians 12, the body needs members who are not interchangeable; in Acts 6:1–7, a dispute across cultural lines is resolved by changing arrangements, not by telling the offended to stop complaining; and Romans 14–15 calls believers to welcome one another amid contested practices. This is no mere slogan. It is the only kind of unity the New Testament actually describes.
But biblical reconciliation is not relativism. Romans 14 does not give us permission to recast every injustice as a matter of taste. Contempt, coercion, and deliberate falsehood call for correction, not equal speaking time (Mouw, 2010; Muehlhoff & Langer, 2020). The claim is narrower and harder: we can honor a person while examining an argument, and heal a relationship without pretending the disagreement has disappeared.
What healing could look like
I would not begin with a congregational debate. I would start smaller: a multigenerational gathering of grandparents, parents, and adult children from two or three families, meeting for one evening in a church with one pastor and three board elders.
Write down the purpose first. Put one line on the invitation: We won’t campaign for anyone; we’ll examine one subject through Scripture and evidence, and no one has to agree.
Start with experience, not the issue. Instead of asking, “what do you think of affirmative action,” ask, "what experience shaped how you see this?" and "what do you think the other generation does not understand about your life?” Experiments by Kalla and Broockman with 230 canvassers and 6,869 voters found that nonjudgmental exchanges of personal narratives modestly and durably shifted exclusionary attitudes (Kalla & Broockman, 2020), though Santoro and Broockman (2022) found that the effects vary by topic and fade over time. The goal of the first evening is modest: make the next one possible.
Separate values from facts, policies, and loyalties. Ask four questions: What moral commitments guide us? What is happening, and how do we know? Which policy is most likely to help? What fear or loyalty makes this difficult to examine? Keeping these questions distinct prevents a disputed prediction from becoming an immediate verdict on someone's faith.
Hear the older voice first and mean it. Use Mutual Invitation: let the grandparent speak without correction and the grandchild speak without dismissal. Voice depends on how the room is structured, not simply on whether people are invited to participate (Karpowitz & Mendelberg, 2014).
Measure more than attendance: Did both generations speak? Could someone accurately state the other side’s view? Is anyone willing to come back?
The church as the room where it can be said
For a Chinese immigrant church considering its long move toward becoming a Chinese heritage church, this is not a side issue but a test of whether we can sustain a shared life across generations. If younger members may serve but not question, translate but not interpret, and inherit duties but not take part in moral discernment, we have not yet built a church that belongs to both; and if younger leaders assume that maturity means dismissing the immigrant generation's fears, we have failed in the other direction.
I do not think a 1.5-generation pastor can manufacture peace between a grandmother and a grandchild. I do believe the church is the one institution that can offer them the room their family gave up decades ago, and that a pastor who belongs to both generations is the one person positioned to open it. Reconciliation is not the same as agreement. It is the harder thing: telling the truth, staying at the table, and loving each other while the argument is still open. After the wave passes, that is the work that remains.
References
Bharath, D. (2024, October 17). Asian American evangelicals' theology is conservative. But that doesn't mean they vote that way. Associated Press. https://apnews.com/article/election-2024-asian-american-evangelicals-voters-9d40ec99fbb51c56f5f08a23ab6cda9e
Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
Edmondson, A. C., & Lei, Z. (2014). Psychological safety: The history, renaissance, and future of an interpersonal construct. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 1, 23–43. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-031413-091305
Friedman, E. H. (2007). A failure of nerve: Leadership in the age of the quick fix (Rev. ed.). Church Publishing.
Guo, M., Lemke, A., & Dong, X. (2022). Sources of intergenerational conflict in Chinese immigrant families in the United States. Journal of Family Issues, 43(9), 2275–2294. https://doi.org/10.1177/0192513X211030724
Kalla, J. L., & Broockman, D. E. (2020). Reducing exclusionary attitudes through interpersonal conversation: Evidence from three field experiments. American Political Science Review, 114(2), 410–425. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055419000923
Karpowitz, C. F., & Mendelberg, T. (2014). The silent sex: Gender, deliberation, and institutions. Princeton University Press.
Law, E. H. F. (1993). The wolf shall dwell with the lamb: A spirituality for leadership in a multicultural community. Chalice Press.
McDevitt, M., & Chaffee, S. (2002). From top-down to trickle-up influence: Revisiting assumptions about the family in political socialization. Political Communication, 19(3), 281–301. https://doi.org/10.1080/01957470290055501
Morrison, E. W., & Milliken, F. J. (2000). Organizational silence: A barrier to change and development in a pluralistic world. Academy of Management Review, 25(4), 706–725. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2000.3707697
Mouw, R. J. (2010). Uncommon decency: Christian civility in an uncivil world (Rev. and expanded ed.). IVP Books.
Muehlhoff, T., & Langer, R. (2020). Winsome conviction: Disagreeing without dividing the church. IVP.
Oetzel, J. G., & Ting-Toomey, S. (2003). Face concerns in interpersonal conflict: A cross-cultural empirical test of the face-negotiation theory. Communication Research, 30(6), 599–624. https://doi.org/10.1177/0093650203257841
Pew Research Center. (2023, October 11). Religion among Asian Americans. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2023/10/11/religion-among-asian-americans/
Pew Research Center. (2025, July 10). In a 2022 survey, most Americans opposed churches endorsing political candidates. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/07/10/in-a-2022-survey-most-americans-opposed-churches-endorsing-political-candidates/
Radner, E. (2012). A brutal unity: The spiritual politics of the Christian church. Baylor University Press.
Santoro, E., & Broockman, D. E. (2022). The promise and pitfalls of cross-partisan conversations for reducing affective polarization: Evidence from randomized experiments. Science Advances, 8(25), eabn5515. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abn5515
Wong, J. S. (2006). Democracy's promise: Immigrants and American civic institutions. University of Michigan Press.
Wong, J. S. (2018). Immigrants, evangelicals, and politics in an era of demographic change. Russell Sage Foundation.
Wong, J., Ramakrishnan, S. K., Lee, T., & Junn, J. (2011). Asian American political participation: Emerging constituents and their political identities. Russell Sage Foundation.
Yang, F. (1999). Chinese Christians in America: Conversion, assimilation, and adhesive identities. Pennsylvania State University Press.
Yoder, J. H. (1992). Body politics: Five practices of the Christian community before the watching world. Discipleship Resources.

Interestingly enough this issue doe not only affect different generations but even within the same generation. In any typical gathering made up of people from various walks of life there's bound to be differences not only culturally, but economically, and politically too. It's always a challenge as to how the pastor should handle the differences in opinion especially when both points of view do not break with scripture. Should a pastor then always take the middle of the road stance and present support for both points of view?
ReplyDeleteThe 'middle road' is often the path of non-conflict. However, is that how one really feels? There are topics I am on one side of rather than on the fence about. In such a case, this is where wisdom, conviction, and 'winsomeness' come in. Debates and arguments don't 'settle' anything, as I found. However, it is equally true that 'wishy-washy' isn't what the Scripture says either.
DeleteI am not trying to win an argument, but to state what I know and what I believe.
Delete