The Necessary Disruption: Transformation and the Chinese Immigrant Church
A reflection by a 1.5 gen Chinese-American pastor | Part 3 of 3
← Back to Part 2 — Gray Temples, Empty Pews: What Does Faithfulness Look Like Now?
Every Chinese immigrant church I have encountered is, in
some form, considering change.
Some are considering it with urgency: the fiscal cliff is
approaching, the congregation is shrinking, the neighborhood has shifted, and
the English ministry left three years ago. Some are considering it with
cautious optimism: new energy has arrived, a pastoral transition has opened
space, and there is a real question about what comes next. Some are considering
it with the particular dread of institutions that sense, deep down, that the
change required is not an upgrade but something closer to death and
resurrection.
All three are right to consider it. The research is
unambiguous: an estimated 70% to 80% of second-generation adults leave their
home churches after high school (Cha, Kang, & Lee, 2006; Lee, 1996; Li,
2020). The theological frameworks that produced that departure,
faithfulness-as-endurance, success-as-attendance, and cultural preservation as
spiritual mandate, were examined in Part 2. Now the question becomes practical
and urgent: What does transformation actually look like, and where do
you begin when the answer depends entirely on where you are?
The question is not whether to transform. It is how, and the
how depends enormously on the life-cycle stage of the congregation doing the
asking. A church planting its first generation has very different leverage than
a congregation at plateau, and both are in a fundamentally different position
from a church whose founding generation is aging into its final years. What
works in one stage may actively harm in another. The grace is that each stage
has genuine possibilities, but only if leaders are honest about which stage
they are actually in.
A Necessary Caution About Mainland Chinese Newcomers
Before turning to each life stage, one widespread assumption
deserves honest scrutiny, not because it hasn't been raised before, but because
it surfaces in a new and more urgent form when the question shifts from what
is happening to what should we do.
Many plateaued and declining Chinese immigrant churches,
observing the continued arrival of mainland Chinese graduate students and
professionals, have quietly structured their renewal strategy around this
population. The hope is understandable. New immigrants need community.
Settlement crises historically create genuine spiritual openness. And the
campus-to-church pipeline, the BSG origin story traced in Part 1, built these
congregations in the first place.
But this hope, however understandable, does not hold under
examination in the current environment. As Part 1 documented in detail, the
fourth wave of mainland Chinese newcomers, economic migrants, fu'erdai,
and run-wave professionals arrives under very different conditions
than the xinqiao who built these churches. Many carry the same
language and ethnicity, but not the immigrant vulnerability that made the BSG
model so effective. They require patient, apologetics-intensive engagement more
than institutional incorporation (Yang, 1999). Immigration patterns are also
shifting under geopolitical pressure and tightening visa policy, making
long-range institutional planning on this basis unreliable.
More fundamentally, and this is the point that connects
directly to the life-stage discernment that follows, a church that defers
structural transformation in the hope that new arrivals will replenish it is
not pursuing renewal. It is repeating the same substitution that Part 2
identified as the core theological problem: counting heads rather than
addressing the governance failures, generational exclusion, and discipleship
failures that created the crisis. A plateaued congregation that does not change
its structure will offer mainland newcomers the same high-PDI governance, the
same unresolved generational tensions, and the same dysfunctional institutional
culture that drove the previous generation away. The newcomer is not a solution
to the succession problem. The solution to the succession problem is solving
the succession problem.
What follows, then, assumes that genuine structural
transformation, not demographic replenishment, is the goal. The pathways differ
significantly depending on where a congregation is in its life cycle, but the
starting posture is the same for all of them: honest diagnosis of the stage you
are actually in, rather than the stage you wish you were.
For the Newly Established Church: Build What You Wish Had
Existed
If you are a newer congregation, planted in the last ten to
fifteen years and still in the formative phase before institutional culture has
fully hardened, you possess what established churches would give almost
anything for: the freedom to build generational architecture from the start
rather than renovating it after the fact. The research on the Silent Exodus is
your most important asset because it is a detailed, decades-long map of
exactly what NOT to do.
The first structural decision is whether to build an English
ministry or avoid the category entirely. The Duplex and Triplex models,
parallel Chinese-language and English-language services under a single
hierarchical board, are well-documented pathways toward the generational
stagnation that breaks up congregations a generation later (Chiu, 2022; Wong,
E., 2015). The alternative that emerging research consistently recommends is
the Partner Church model: planting an English-speaking congregation
from the beginning as a fully independent entity with its own budget,
constitution, and governance while maintaining a clear relational and missional
pathway for the young people of the Chinese-speaking congregation to move into
it as they mature (Chiu, 2022). This is not a separation of two churches but an
intentional interdependence: the first generation actively supports the second
generation's congregation rather than governing it.
The second decision is the profile of pastoral leadership.
New churches should actively recruit 1.5-generation pastors, those who arrived
in America as children or teenagers, as cultural bridge figures (Kwan, 2016;
Law, 1982, as cited in Chiu, 2022). The 1.5-generation pastor carries both the
"American-ness" to build genuine relational trust with
English-speaking young adults and the "Chinese-ness" to maintain
credibility with first-generation founders. That bicultural competency is not
merely a communication advantage; it is a structural requirement for any
congregation that intends to hold two generations in genuine rather than
nominal community.
The third decision, and the one most likely to be deferred
until it is too late, is the explicit theological framing of the congregation's
missional identity from the beginning. Tung (2009) warns against the
"perpetual immigrant" trap: the tendency of new Chinese immigrant
congregations to build their entire institutional identity around serving newly
arrived first-generation members, with no theological framework for what the
congregation becomes as those members assimilate and their children grow up (as
cited in Kwan, 2016). The congregation that understands itself from its first
year as a diaspora community on the way to somewhere, not a
permanent enclave, will form disciples with a missional posture rather than an
institutional loyalty. Wan's threefold framework, missions to, through,
and beyond the diaspora, is not merely a missiological
category; it is a founding ecclesiological claim (Wan & Casey, 2014). The
congregation that inhabits it from the beginning will not need to be convinced
of it when the hard decisions arrive a decade later.
For the Plateaued Church: The Harder Renovation
If you lead a congregation that has plateaued, stable in
size but not growing, with a first-generation core and a shrinking or recently
departed English ministry, the conversation is significantly harder. You are
not building a new house. You are renovating a house where people are living,
with all the disruption, negotiation, and relational costs that renovation
entails.
The most important diagnosis is structural, not
programmatic. Plateaued Chinese immigrant churches most commonly find
themselves in the Duplex or Triplex stage: a separate English service exists
but remains hierarchically subordinate to the Chinese-language board (Chiu,
2022; Wong, E., 2015). The English-speaking congregation has visibility but not
authority; representation but not governance. Young adults who show up to lead
discover quickly that the institution was not designed for them. The result is
what Tow (2008) describes as "second-class citizenship," a felt
reality no amount of welcome programming can overcome because it is embedded in
the governing structure itself.
The structural move that research consistently identifies as
the necessary intervention is the transition to a Townhouse model:
granting the English congregation autonomous authority over its budget,
pastoral direction, and future (Wong, H., 1998; Chiu, 2022). In a high-PDI
institutional culture where authority flows from age and position rather than
from collaborative discernment, this transition is a profound act of cultural
and theological reorientation (Li, 2020, p. 80; Shin & Silzer, 2016).
First-generation leaders who built the institution will experience this
transition as loss, because it is loss: of control, of centrality, of the
institutional form they sacrificed to create. The pastor who leads this process
without honestly acknowledging it will be defeated by resistance before the
transition is complete.
Structural transfer, however, addresses only part of the
problem. Even if a congregation successfully redistributes board authority,
the transition will remain incomplete if its understanding of discipleship continues
to operate within the earlier framework: faithfulness measured primarily by
endurance, success measured by attendance, and cultural preservation treated as
a spiritual mandate. In that case, newly empowered English-ministry leaders may
simply reproduce the same theological assumptions within a revised governing structure.
Meaningful renovation therefore requires movement on two fronts at once: the
decentralization of governing authority and a substantive reassessment of the
church’s theology of discipleship. Congregations must ask whether their
historic measures of spiritual maturity have actually formed people into
Christlikeness, or whether they have more often reinforced the expectations
placed on the “well-behaved, obedient, high-achieving” children of immigrants. The
practices of discipleship must also be reconsidered: moving beyond the mere
transmission of doctrine and regulation of behavior toward practices that
accompany people through genuine spiritual formation; moving beyond one-directional
pulpit instruction toward communal relationships capable of sustaining
questions, struggle, and honest theological reflection. Without this deeper
theological renewal, structural change risks becoming a reorganization of
existing assumptions rather than a genuine transformation.
This is also why cross-cultural training for
first-generation elders and board members is not optional but structural. Shin
and Silzer (2016) make the crucial point that many first-generation leaders'
preferences for hierarchical governance are not experienced as cultural choices
but as biblical norms: the way faithful, honorable people lead a church.
Workshops on cultural intelligence that help leaders distinguish their
Confucian inheritance from the actual governance patterns of the New Testament
church are not diversity programming; they are ecclesiological formation (Li,
2020, p. 55; Shin & Silzer, 2016). This work is slow. It is also the only
work that produces lasting structural change rather than cosmetic
reorganization.
Beyond governance, the plateaued congregation must also
address what researchers identify as its spiritual atmosphere. Lau (2017) and
Wong, E. (2015) both observe that plateaued churches drift into
"maintenance mode," organizing their energy around institutional
survival rather than spiritual transformation. The congregation becomes, functionally,
an ethnic social club with religious programming rather than a faith community
with missional purpose (Lau, 2017; Wong, E., 2015). Reversing this drift
requires pastoral preaching and teaching that names the drift honestly and
calls the community back to its original missional identity. It also requires
the courage to let some programs die: to stop resourcing activities that serve
institutional nostalgia and redirect that energy toward the spiritual formation
and cross-cultural competency of the congregation actually present.
For the Church Near the End: The Holy Work of Faithful
Closure
Some Chinese immigrant churches are not in a season of
renewal. They are in a season of faithful completion. The congregation is
elderly, the building is aging, the financial reserves are declining, and there
is no realistic successor generation within the existing community. This is not
a failure of faith. It is the natural life cycle of an institution born in a
specific historical moment for a specific population, and the question is not
how to avoid the ending but how to steward it faithfully.
Jeung (2005) and Chang (2015) observe that ethnic churches
only thrive through the end of their life cycle when older members are willing
to relinquish power and give new leaders genuine authority to
make radical reforms, not incremental adjustments but structural transformation
(Chang, 2015). This may mean merging with a younger, multiethnic congregation,
transferring building assets to a church plant, or formally dissolving and
distributing resources to kingdom partners, rather than allowing the
institution to die slowly as its assets erode.
One practical option that some congregations have pursued is
reorienting their identity toward their surrounding neighborhood. Liao (2022)
argues that Chinese heritage churches facing demographic decline should
consider removing "Chinese" from their name and public identity as a
deliberate signal of missional openness, what he calls "Changing the
C," in order to lower the barrier of entry for non-Chinese neighbors
(Liao, 2022; Chuang, 2016; Quen, 2018). This is not a renunciation of heritage.
It is the heritage expressing itself in a new form, consistent with Wan's
vision of the diaspora community as a mission force rather than a cultural
refuge (Wan & Casey, 2014).
A second possibility is what Helen Lee (2014) calls
the "Boomerang Effect": the documented pattern of some
second-generation adults returning to ethnic churches in their 30s and 40s
after marriage, children, and a renewed search for cultural rootedness,
becoming available as a new primary leadership tier (Lee, H., 2014; Kwan, 2016;
Quen, 2018). This is a genuine possibility, but it carries a crucial condition:
these returning adults will stay and lead only if the institutional culture has
actually changed since they left. A congregation that welcomes back the second
generation while maintaining the same high-PDI governance, the same cultural
preservation mandate, and the same subordinate role for English-speaking
leadership will experience the Boomerang Effect as a brief reprieve rather than
genuine renewal.
For congregations where none of these options are viable,
where the community is simply too small, too old, and too financially strained
to sustain missional reorientation, the most faithful act may be the hardest
one: closing well. Kwan (2016) offers the aircraft carrier
metaphor: the first generation's ultimate purpose is not to sustain the carrier
indefinitely but to sail far enough that the "fighters," the next
generation, can be launched to reach targets the carrier itself cannot reach
(Kwan, 2016). An institution that ends by launching others through asset
transfer, through the blessing of departing members toward other congregations,
and through the deliberate transmission of its accumulated faith and wisdom has
not failed. It has fulfilled its purpose.
The pastoral work of leading a congregation through a
faithful ending deserves far more theological development than the Chinese
immigrant church has given it. Chinese cultural norms around face, around
avoiding death as a topic, and around the shame attached to institutional
failure make honest conversation about closure structurally very difficult
(Kwan, 2016, p. 3; Sohn, 2017, p. 264). The pastor who can create space for
that conversation, who can preach honestly about mortality, about the grain of
wheat, about the resurrection logic that runs through every genuine Christian
ending, is offering this community something more valuable than another
revitalization strategy.
The Through-Line: Diaspora as Vocation
Across all three life stages, the through-line is not a
strategy but a theology. Wan's diaspora missiology refuses the framing that
treats the Chinese immigrant church as merely a cultural institution to be
sustained or mourned (Wan & Casey, 2014). The scattering was providential.
The churches it produced, the campus Bible study groups, the Triplex
congregations, the English ministries, and the church plants, were vessels for
a mission larger than any of them.
As Part 2 argued, the crisis is not simply a matter of
imbalanced governance. It reflects a broader theological framework in which
faithfulness has been reduced to endurance, success to attendance, and cultural
preservation to spiritual mandate. If a church changes only who occupies seats
of authority without renewing its account of discipleship, spiritual maturity,
and the practices by which lives are actually formed in Christ, then the
transfer of authority will remain incomplete. A new generation may be entrusted
with leadership while still being evaluated by inherited criteria that have
already proven insufficient. Genuine transformation, therefore, must be
threefold: a transfer of structural authority, a recalibration of theological
aims, and a renewal of discipleship practices. Only then can the congregation
become a community that forms people through the transforming life of Christ,
rather than an institution with a revised governance structure but the same underlying
measures of spiritual maturity.
The question now pressing on every Chinese immigrant
congregation, regardless of its stage, is whether it can hold its institutional
form loosely enough to let the mission reshape it. That question cannot be
answered by a program or a model. It can only be answered by pastoral leaders
who have done the inner work: leaders who have grieved their own losses,
examined their own inherited theologies of success, and arrived at a place
where they can say with genuine conviction: this church belongs to God,
and God's purposes for the Chinese diaspora are not finished. The form
may change. The vessel may break. The mission continues.
That is the story we are in. And it is far from over.
← Back to Part 2 — Gray Temples, Empty Pews: What Does Faithfulness Look Like Now?
Sources
- Cha, P., Kang, S. S., & Lee, H. (Eds.). (2006). Growing healthy Asian American churches: Ministry insights from groundbreaking congregations. InterVarsity Press.
- Chang, S. S. (2015). Beyond first and second generation: Developing a strategy to reach the emerging third-generation Korean-Americans (DMin dissertation, Talbot School of Theology).
- Chiu, C. (2022). Time for a new model: The case for English Ministry partner churches for the Chinese immigrant church in the USA (Doctoral project, Biola University).
- Chuang, D. J. (2016). MultiAsian.Church: A future for Asian Americans in a multiethnic world. Self-published.
- Jeung, R. (2005). Faithful generations: Race and new Asian American churches. Rutgers University Press.
- Kwan, K. T. N. (2016). Building a two-generational Chinese immigrant church for world mission (Doctoral project, Biola University).
- Lau, T. (2017). Mosaic ministry: Challenges and opportunities of intergenerational ministry among Chinese churches (Doctoral project).
- Law, G. (1982). The Chinese way of doing things. (As cited in Chiu, 2022).
- Lee, H. (1996, August 12). Silent exodus. Christianity Today, 40(9), 50–53.
- Lee, H. (2014, October 14). The boomerang effect. Christianity Today.
- Li, A. (2020). An analysis of the cultural and leadership differences among leaders in the Chinese immigrant church in America (Doctoral project, Biola University).
- Liao, E. (2022, May 18). What is a Chinese heritage church? Chinese Heritage Church Collaborative. https://chineseheritagechurch.com/what/
- O. Park (2021). Are we returning to Egypt? A question for Korean immigrant churches (Doctoral project, Biola University).
- Quen, S. (2018). Reaching and retaining American-born Asian Millennials at Bay Area Chinese Bible Church (Doctoral project).
- Shin, B. C., & Silzer, S. T. (2016). Tapestry of grace: Untangling the cultural complexities in Asian American life and ministry. Wipf & Stock.
- Sohn, E. (2017). Attitudes of Asian American Christians towards the ethnic churches they left (Doctoral project, Alliance Theological Seminary).
- Tow, F. K. (2008). Training American-born Chinese pastors to minister in a predominantly Chinese bicultural church (DMin dissertation, Asbury Theological Seminary).
- Tung, J. (2009). Increasing the pool of ministry workers. In Completing the face of the Chinese church in America. FACE.
- Wan, E., & Casey, A. (2014). Church planting among immigrants in US urban centers: The "where", "why", and "how" of diaspora missiology in action. IDS-USA / Western Seminary.
- Wong, E. (2015). How am I going to grow up: An exploration of congregational transition among second-generation Chinese Canadian Evangelicals and servant-leadership (Doctoral project).
- Wong, H. (1998). Coming together or coming apart? TRACC Publications.
- Yang, F. (1999). Chinese Christians in America: Conversion, assimilation, and adhesive identities. Pennsylvania State University Press.

Some brief comments/questions that come into mind on each life cycle: (1) For the Newly Established Church - assuming more churches do make this decision, are there enough 1.5 generation pastors available to answer the call? (2) For the Plateaued Church - the "Townhouse model" is a tough sell especially when an autonomous English congregation cannot support itself and still heavily relies on the Chinese congregation. (3) For the Church Near the End - this is the one that really emotionally hits home. By this time there may not be enough funds to even maintain a pastor to help with the demise of a church. The few in number that still remain tends to just hang on as there are still two or more willing to gather. Unfortunately, death of anyone or anything is never easy.
ReplyDeleteYou're right—none of these suggestions are 'easy,' 'normal,' or 'traditional,' since those approaches have already been tried and have known results. Start with the end (or the midpoint) in mind, blending waterfall and agile methodologies—much like Jesus foresaw the cross in eternity past. The real work is encouraging denominational leaders and church planters to nurture the 1.5 gen so they can grasp the vision, ideally leading to more English-led Chinese heritage churches where 1.5/2.0 lead with 1.0 alongside. I'm still walking through this in my own church, as God teaches me to lead with more care than command.
DeleteOnce again, this is pretty well thought out. I know what you're trying to say when it comes to what you're calling the Townhouse model. To many this could really be referred to as a church plant. But to others this is also a very hard pill to swallow. The tendency is going to still be separate language congregations under the same roof with the same board and etc. This is especially true when the older congregation may have young kids they want to keep in the same church family. It's also obviously more convenient to drop the kids off in the room next door than elsewhere in the neighborhood. The English congregation typically cannot be financially independent for quite sometime so would heavily relying on the Chinese congregation to provide support. The other thing going for the multi-language congregation under the same roof is the success of those very large chinese churches in southern california where this unity model has not only succeeded but still thrive ie: First Chinese Baptist Church of Los Angeles and a number of church plants that came out using the same multi-language congregation model. But perhaps we can also look at how a number of the Japanese with English congregation churches coexisted together but eventually separated into very independent churches ie: Evergreen Baptist Church of Los Angeles.
ReplyDeleteThe thought is looking into a structural change, actually. It is where church governance changes over time from immigrant identity, language, and practices to heritage identity, English leadership, and practices. The "townhouse" is the middle phase, much like FCBC LA, Houston Chinese Church, or Boston Chinese Evangelic Church. For small churches, this can be difficult, not because of resources alone, but about "letting go" and "trust God"...
Delete