The Fall Festival Question
Last week I spent an afternoon doing what I do every October. I folded invitation flyers, prepared candy and carnival games in the fellowship hall, and handed out fliers for our Fall Festival.
This year we moved it to Friday the 30th, not the 31st, because of a school bell. The families we want to reach come from the elementary school a few steps away, and on Friday the children and their parents can walk over as school lets out instead of coming back after dark. Better odds of meeting a parent who has never been inside our building.
The date moved. And every year I sign off on it with a reservation I have never said out loud in a meeting: I am not sure what we are doing.
The question underneath the question
The seventh month of the lunar calendar is ghost month, and I have to be honest about my credentials on this. We left Hong Kong when I was less than ten. I never lived through a ghost month; I only have secondhand accounts. Old Cantonese films with the paper offerings and the wronged spirit, and older relatives lowering their voices about certain nights. Don't stay out late. Don't hang the washing outside after dark. Don't turn around if someone calls your name on the street. I inherited the caution without ever having been afraid of anything.
Which is its own 1.5-generation condition, and it is why I can say this without dismissing anyone's fear. Two cultures, an ocean apart, keep a season in which the dead come close, and everybody gets careful. Neither season is really about the dead. Both are about us, about how you live when you know you are going to die. And every culture answers that with ritual: appease it, avoid it, or laugh at it.
So the question I keep hearing in our churches is the small one: should Christians do Halloween? Underneath it is the one I have avoided for twenty years. What does Christ do with a culture?
Five old answers
H. Richard Niebuhr wrote Christ and Culture in 1951. It is still the book everyone cites and almost nobody rereads. He called the book an essay on "the double wrestle of the church with its Lord and with the cultural society with which it lives in symbiosis" (Niebuhr, 1951). His definition of culture is worth more than the famous typology: the "artificial, secondary environment" which we superimpose on the natural, comprising language, habits, ideas, beliefs, customs, social organization (Niebuhr, 1951).
Five answers follow. I have seen all of them at work in our own church, and I am not sure I like where we land.
Christ against culture. Tertullian, the desert monks, Tolstoy: reject the culture's claim on your loyalty. Niebuhr's chapter heading is "A Necessary and Inadequate Position": necessary, because culture does make claims it has no right to make, and inadequate, because a church that only refuses has nothing to say to the world it refuses. In our church it sounds like: "We don't do Halloween," said flatly, then silence, because the next sentence was never worked out.
The Christ of culture. The church does what the culture does and pastes a verse on top. Niebuhr's examples: the Gnostics, Ritschl's culture-Protestantism. In our church, it looks like this: the same candy, the same costumes, a prayer at the front, and a count at the end. Nothing is judged, and nothing is healed, and the event's success is measured by the crowd.
Christ above culture. Keep the form, add a layer. The synthesist's move: Clement of Alexandria in Niebuhr's telling, the Fall Festival in mine. In our church it sounds like: "We don't do Halloween, we do a Harvest Festival." Halloween becomes harvest, ghosts become nothing, and the shape of the evening does not change. I will come back to this one, because it is the type our churches actually live in, and I think it is the type I have been pastoring.
Christ and culture in paradox. Two authorities held together without resolution. Luther's answer, and in our church it looks like two calendars that never meet: the children trick-or-treat with their friends on Friday, the church says nothing on Sunday, and nobody reconciles the two.
Christ the transformer of culture. Augustine, Calvin, Wesley: they take up culture and turn it inside out. Not a boycott, not a copy. The fear gets answered. In our church it looks like the rare year we went out instead of inviting people in. More on that below. Niebuhr closes with a decision, not a verdict.
The tell is the rename
Here is what I keep circling.
"We don't do Halloween, we do a Harvest Festival." Say that sentence slowly and look at what changed. The candy did not change. The pumpkins did not change. The costumes didn't change, and neither did the date or the children coming through the door. One thing changed, and it is a word.
I have run that event, and I would rather the neighborhood children be on our lawn than on somebody's porch. Honestly, we took a night we were uneasy about, kept everything in it, changed the name on the flyer, and called the renaming faithfulness.
Once I recognized the shape of that move, I couldn’t stop seeing it. A few years ago, our church gave the ministry I lead a new name and put a new English word on the door. We talked about it for a year. But what actually changed in how the congregation is governed—who decides, whose money pays for it, whose calendar sets the year? Very little. I’ve spent a decade doing to a ministry what I’ve been doing to a holiday, and it took a stack of candy and a flyer to make me see it.
So the Fall Festival isn’t really about Halloween. It’s about whether this church transforms anything at all—or simply changes labels. Both are on display on the lawn this Friday, and one of them is easier to live with.
The one October I think we got near it
Years ago, with the English youth and young-adult groups I led, we did something different, and I haven't stopped thinking about it. We sent out teams of two with bags of candy and gospel tracts and told them to knock on doors and give, not take.
Reverse trick-or-treat. You knock on a stranger's door, hand them a treat bag, and say two things. "God bless you." And: "There is a church nearby that prays for you and your family." Then you leave. That is the whole script. Nobody holds a door open, nobody has to defend a position, and nobody has to be anything. A team of two, an hour on the sidewalk, one sentence and a bag of candy.
Churches everywhere do it, and it is written up as a first step in servant evangelism (Sibley, 2017; Klausman, 2017). What stays with me is what it did to the students. You cannot rehearse a blessing for an hour and come back unchanged.
The Chinese-speaking groups wanted nothing to do with it, and I didn't argue, a mistake I've regretted for years.
But here is the part that has been working on me. That practice is gone. It died when those students graduated and scattered, leaving nothing behind: no line in a job description, no place on the calendar, no budget row, no name in anybody's minutes. It was real, it answered the season instead of dodging it, and it was never once written down, so the next pastor inherited a Fall Festival and a story about something that used to happen.
James Davison Hunter calls what survives "faithful presence," and the load-bearing word in his definition is institutional: Christian practice is "not only individual but institutional" (Hunter, 2010). We had the practice. We never had the institution.
What has changed since 1951
Niebuhr is the beginning, not the end.
Craig Carter's Rethinking Christ and Culture (2006) makes the sharpest charge. Niebuhr wrote inside Christendom, where the church's cultural power could be assumed permanent and, on the whole, a good thing — so his five types answer how should the church relate to a culture it still largely owns, which is not our question (Carter, 2006).
D. A. Carson's Christ and Culture Revisited (2008) comes at it from the other direction. Once the whole biblical story is in view, he argues, to speak of different "models" of the Christ-and-culture relationship "begins to look misleading" (Carson, 2008). Then the line I have wanted in a board meeting for ten years: "That all exemplifications of faith, Christian and otherwise, are necessarily expressed within forms that are cultural cannot reasonably be denied" (Carson, 2008).
Read that against our board arguments. If every expression of faith arrives in cultural clothing, then both our congregations are wearing clothes, and neither form is faithful by nature. The fight at our board tables, Chinese or English, hymnal or chorus, is not a fight between faithfulness and assimilation. It is a fight between two translations, conducted as though one of them were the original.
K. K. Yeo's What Has Jerusalem to Do with Beijing? names the piece Niebuhr never had (Yeo, 2018). His five types are Western answers to a Western question; Yeo's contrapuntal reading holds two worlds in tension instead of replacing one with the other, which is the daily question for a 1.5-generation pastor. Not how Christ relates to a culture, but which world I am standing in when I decide.
And there is a writer in the Hong Kong diaspora. Wu Chi Wai, writing from Bristol, published a piece this month arguing that the Chinese church is functionally world-weary: dualistic in its theological thinking, treating the world as enemy territory to escape rather than the field God created and is still redeeming (Wu, 2026). His sharpest line lands on this week. Many believers, he says, fear October 31, 萬聖夜 (All Hallows' Eve or Halloween), more than November 1, 諸聖日 (All Saints' Day), and the communion of the saints.
I have been quoting that sentence to myself all month. It stings because I am the man with the tracts in the fellowship hall.
In fairness to the old instinct
I do not want to write six hundred words that make my elders look like the problem.
The fear is real and it did not come from nowhere. Ghost month is not a superstition the church invented; it is a social world with real costs, and Chinese Christians in Asia do not have the option of treating the spirit world as a philosophical concept. Justin Tan, coeditor of Spirit Wind, puts it better than I could: Christians reject the idea that ghosts are released from hell because God reigns over the whole world, "but out of that, they still have a fear of the supernatural" (Ong, 2022). The fear is the pastoral fact. Everything else is tactics.
Nor is the "Halloween is pagan" claim as settled as both sides pretend. Ronald Hutton's history of the British ritual year, the standard scholarly treatment, spends real energy debunking what both sides repeat about Halloween's origins (Hutton, 1996). I would rather not base a pastoral decision on a history I haven't read carefully.
And our churches are not unusual here. Lifeway Research surveyed 1,000 Protestant pastors and found that more than 90% encourage their congregations to mark October 31 in some way, from avoiding it entirely to inviting neighbors to a church event; 13% discourage it outright. The fastest-growing practice since 2016 is telling people to hand out gospel tracts to children who ring the doorbell, up from 26% to 34% (McFarlan Miller, 2022). Americans spent a projected $13.5 billion on Halloween this year, averaging $115 each (National Retail Federation, 2026).
So the answer for a church that is afraid isn't a better-run party.
Three things I could actually do
I have a bad habit of ending in exhortation when I write about something like this. So here is what would go into the written record, all of it sized for a congregation with one pastor and a few elders, which is the size of congregation I actually have.
Say on paper what the night is. One sentence in the bulletin, one in the newsletter. If it is a Halloween party for the neighborhood children, say that, and say why we are holding it. If it is a harvest thanksgiving, then let us thank God for something in particular. Our tradition already does this in the other direction: Chinese churches keep Mid-Autumn Festival, a genuine harvest and reunion festival, and the Christian reflection on it does not rename it; it fills it (ChinaSource Team, 2019). We know how. We just did not do it in October.
Name the dead, in the room where we already say names. Our tradition has no All Saints and no liturgical calendar, and I won't import one. A church that adopts a rite it has no home for has done what this post complains about. But we do have a room where we speak names out loud: every Friday night, a small group of us works through a prayer list, one name at a time. Once a year, that list should include our dead. It is the one thing a renamed party can never reach, and it costs something: the list would have to include people who left with the second generation and were never mentioned again.
Write the good thing down before it leaves. If we do something that answers the season, it has to land somewhere it can outlive the people who did it: a line in a role description, a slot in the calendar, a row in a budget. Otherwise the next pastor inherits the event and a story.
Who runs the event belongs to the same question. If the same generation runs the Fall Festival every year, the renamed holiday tells me nothing about the church's future, and I should stop pretending it does.
I have not done any of these.
What I want this Friday
On Friday afternoon, the lawn will fill with children whose names I mostly don't know yet, walking over as school lets out, and the man handing out the candy will be a pastor who has been renaming things for years and calling it faithfulness.
This year I would like to learn their names. And before the candy runs out, I would like to say one true sentence to somebody about why we are out there. That is not a strategy. It might be a start.
References
Carson, D. A. (2008). Christ and culture revisited. Wm. B. Eerdmans.
Carter, C. A. (2006). Rethinking Christ and culture: A post-Christendom perspective. Brazos Press.
ChinaSource Team. (2019). Mid-Autumn Festival—A Christian perspective. ChinaSource. https://www.chinasource.org/resource-library/chinese-church-voices/mid-autumn-festival-a-christian-perspective/
Hunter, J. D. (2010). To change the world: The irony, tragedy, and possibility of Christianity in the late modern world. Oxford University Press. https://jamesdavisonhunter.com/to-change-the-world
Hutton, R. (1996). The stations of the sun: A history of the ritual year in Britain. Oxford University Press. https://academic.oup.com/book/1390
Klausman, S. (2017, October 19). 5 creative alternatives to trunk-or-treat. CT Pastors. https://www.christianitytoday.com/pastors/content/5-creative-alternatives-to-trunk-or-treat/
McFarlan Miller, E. (2022, October 31). New poll examines pastors' opinions of Halloween. The Christian Century. https://www.christiancentury.org/news/new-poll-examines-pastors-opinions-halloween
National Retail Federation. (2026). Halloween data and trends. https://nrf.com/research-insights/holiday-data-and-trends/halloween
Niebuhr, H. R. (1951). Christ and culture. Harper & Row.
Ong, I. (2022, August). Filled with the Spirit amid the hungry ghosts. Christianity Today. https://chinasource.org/articles/christians-and-the-hungry-ghost-festival/
Sibley, A. (2017, November 1). 'Reverse trick-or-treating' leads to teenager's salvation. Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. https://swbts.edu/news/reverse-trick-or-treating-leads-to-teenagers-salvation/
Wu, C. W. (2026, October 22). 為何華人教會多是「厭世派」? [Why are most Chinese churches "world-weary"?]. 胡志偉牧師文集. https://chiwaiwu.wordpress.com/2026/10/22/%e7%82%ba%e4%bd%95%e8%8f%af%e4%ba%ba%e6%95%99%e6%9c%83%e5%a4%9a%e6%98%af%e3%80%8c%e5%8e%ad%e4%b8%96%e6%b4%be%e3%80%8d%ef%bc%9f/
Yeo, K. K. (2018). What has Jerusalem to do with Beijing? Biblical interpretation from a Chinese perspective (2nd ed.). Pickwick.

It's always a challenge when it comes to secular holidays which typically do have a big crowd draw like Halloween or even Easter (the jury is still out on if this name is derived from another secular influence). There's even more of a challenge when it comes to the tradition of things done to celebrate those holidays such as wearing costumes or doing egg hunts. But as for Halloween I've seen other names used such as "Trunk or Treat" as you've referenced by Klausman. But in the end, perhaps opening up the church for the community to come and celebrate in a safe environment within church grounds is strong enough of a reason to keep it going regardless of what name is used for any holiday throughout the year.
ReplyDeleteQuite true. We had the Fall Festival at church yesterday, and some kiddos and parents from the elementary school came over. Hearing from the kiddos themselves, asking their parents, and telling them that the church had always done this was particularly heartwarming.
Delete