Reading the Old Testament Without Becoming a Legalist
A member of my Wednesday morning Bible study asked me a question last spring that I should have been able to answer without blinking. "Pastor, were people in the Old Testament saved by keeping the law?"
I gave her an answer that was true and useless. Yes, they kept the law. No, that's not what saved them. Then we moved on, because that's what we do when we don't know how to hold a question. She deserved better.
This summer, a professor of mine answered the same question in print, and his answer rearranged something I had been carrying for years without realizing it was heavy. This post is about what he said, why it matters for churches like the ones we grew up in, and what changes when you finally read the law the way it was written.
The answer that rearranged things
Kenneth Way taught me Old Testament in my master's program. He is a professor at Talbot, and in the summer 2026 issue of Talbot Magazine, he answered a student's question in a column called "That's a Great Question." The question: How were people saved in the Old Testament?
His answer, in short: keeping the torah was never for salvation, because salvation is not attained by works. The torah existed to give people a way to express the faith they already had. God acts first. He rescues Israel from Egypt, and only then does he give them the law. Grace comes first, Sinai second. The law is the gift given to people who have already been freed, and its purpose is disclosure. It shows them who their God is. God's holy character is revealed in the law not so people can reach it, but so people can know him in covenant relationship.
The second half of his answer is the part I keep turning over. The holy status of God's people is not something they achieve. God ascribes it because he chooses to be present with his people. This has never changed, from the Old Covenant to the New. The people of God in the Old Testament and the people of God in the New Testament are identified the same way, by faith, not by genetics, ethnicity, ritual practice, or law observance. Abraham believed, and it was counted to him as righteousness (Genesis 15:6). Caleb and Ruth trusted God based on the revelation they had. And the New Testament says it plainly: you have been saved by grace through faith, and this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works (Ephesians 2:8-9).
I know this theology. I have preached it. But hearing it from the man who taught me the Old Testament, in the context of the law itself, did something. It made me realize how rarely we actually let the Old Testament speak this way in our churches.
And here is the part I want to sit in for a moment. If the law was never the way in, then the whole Old Testament reads differently. Patrick Miller, in his commentary on the Ten Commandments, makes the point that the commandments do not begin with a command at all. They begin with a name and a rescue: "I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt" (Exodus 20:2). Miller calls that preface the lens through which every command must be read. The law is not the terms of entry into the covenant. It is the shape of life for people already inside it (Miller, 2009). Christopher Wright says the same thing from the other end: Old Testament ethics are not a ladder to climb toward God; they are the grateful response of a people who have already been redeemed. The moral life of Israel is covenant-shaped, and covenants in the Bible begin with grace (Wright, 2004). The exodus happened first. The ethics came after. When you miss that order, you do not just misread a few verses. You misread the whole story, because you have put the response in the place of the rescue.
Why the law became a ladder anyway
Here is the uncomfortable part. In Chinese immigrant churches, the law did not stay a gift. It became a ladder. "The law must be kept" became the primary pathway to sanctification and, in practice, the primary evidence that someone was a real Christian. We do not say this out loud, but we live it. The question is how a gift becomes a rulebook, and I think four currents carry it along.
The first is Confucian moral cultivation. We were raised to believe that being a good person is a project of self-improvement, 修身. You work at it, you get better at it, you are graded on it. When the gospel arrives in that grammar, it sounds like moral improvement. Sanctification gets heard as self-cultivation with a Christian label. Fenggang Yang, in his study of Chinese Christians in America, observed exactly this affinity: Chinese Americans who converted often framed their faith in strongly moral terms, and churches that emphasized upright behavior thrived, because the moral frame matched the cultural one (Yang, 1999). The gospel did not replace the ladder. It was absorbed into the ladder, which already had a very good grip on us.
The second is the folk religion merit ledger. Underneath the surface of many of our families is a transactional instinct: you do good, you accumulate credit, you get blessed. 積德. When you carry that ledger into church, keeping the law feels like making deposits with God. The law becomes the price list for a religion of exchange. This is the oldest religious instinct in the world, and it does not retire when you get baptized. It just changes uniforms.
The third is face and witness. In a tight immigrant community, visible behavior is how faith is proven. 守得住 is about honor as much as holiness. If the children are watching, the rules are the sermon, and keeping them is keeping face. The same dynamics appear across the Chinese diaspora, where the congregation's reputation and the family's honor are bound up together, and outward standards become the working measure of faithfulness (ChinaSource, 2023).
The fourth is the way we read the Bible itself. The most common method in our churches is 以經解經, interpreting Scripture by stringing together other Scriptures. Chi Wai Wu has written sharply about this method, and he names two failures underneath it: the naivety of the reader, who thinks he can read without assumptions, and the pride of the reader, who controls the text by fitting it into his own interpretive system (Wu, 2025a). When you read that way, the covenant story disappears. Leviticus becomes a timeless rulebook for next week. The exodus, the rescue, the grace that came first, all of it gets edited out, and the law sits there alone, looking like a set of requirements. Western biblical scholarship has reached the same verdict from a different direction. Sidney Greidanus, in his standard work on preaching the Old Testament, argues that the church lost its ability to preach the Old Testament when it stopped reading individual texts in their historical and redemptive context and started treating them as detached moral oracles (Greidanus, 1999). The critique of proof-texting is not a liberal position. It is what careful readers of both traditions have been saying for a generation. The first three currents gave us the motive to want a ladder. This fourth one built it.
Add a historical layer, and you get the full picture. Wu has also documented the behavior code of Chinese fundamentalism: no smoking, no drinking, no dancing, no cards, no mahjong, no movies, no gambling. In the 1980s, watching a movie violated seminary rules (Wu, 2025b). That code became, for a whole generation, the working definition of holiness. The law was no longer the covenant gift that reveals God. It was the checklist that proves you are in.
None of this is meant as an indictment of our parents' generation. Every one of these currents is understandable. They came from a people who survived on discipline. But the result is the same: a church where "the law must be kept" has become the main road of sanctification, and where many believers cannot name the difference between being made right with God and being good enough for God. The deepest problem is that this is not only practically wrong, but it is also spiritually deadening. A ladder gospel produces people who are exhausted, afraid, and quietly resentful. It also produces a church that cannot see its own children leaving, because by its own metric, everything is working.
How to actually read the law
So what does it look like to read the Old Testament the way it was written?
Start with the preface. The Ten Commandments do not begin with a rule. They begin with a rescue: "I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery" (Exodus 20:2). That verse is the lens for everything after it (Miller, 2009). The commandments are not the terms of entry into the covenant. They shape the life of people already inside it. Read the law as the response of the rescued, and it stops being a ladder and starts being a way of walking with the God who carried you out.
Read the law as disclosure, not as requirement. Every law tells you something about the God who gave it. The laws about rest tell you that God is not anxious. The laws about the vulnerable tell you that God keeps a special file on the orphan and the widow. The laws about worship tell you that God wants to be known, not managed. The law is a self-portrait of God before it is a rulebook for us. Wright pushes this further: the laws about the poor and the alien are not exceptions to the covenant; they are the covenant's center of gravity, because they show what the rescuing God is like. Israel was an ex-slave nation, so Israel was commanded to care for people with no power (Wright, 2004). A ladder religion reads the laws about widows and orphans as extra credit. A covenant religion reads them as a mirror of the God who rescued slaves.
Read the law as story, not as system. John Goldingay makes the case that the Old Testament is fundamentally narrative, a gospel-like account of God's acts, and that Israel's faith was confessed in story form long before it was codified in rules (Goldingay, 2003). The law is a chapter inside a story, not a standalone constitution. When we read it as a standalone constitution, we are not reading the text we have. We are reading a genre the Bible never wrote.
Read the law forward to its telos. Paul says the end of the law is Christ (Romans 10:4). Not the abolition of the law, but its goal. Everything the law was pointing toward is fulfilled in him. And Jeremiah promised something the law could never deliver: a day when the law would be written on hearts instead of tablets (Jeremiah 31:33). Ezekiel promised a new heart and the Spirit inside us (Ezekiel 36:26-27). The Old Testament itself knew that the problem was never the rules; it was us, and that the answer was not more rules but a new heart. Greidanus's method is exactly this discipline: every Old Testament text is read first in its own time, then traced toward its fulfillment in Christ (Greidanus, 1999). The Spirit does what the checklist cannot. That is why a Christian can say, with full honesty, that the law is holy and good, and also that he does not live by it. He lives by the one the law was pointing to.
And here is the part our churches need most: sanctification is not powered by the law. Jerry Bridges spent a lifetime insisting that the gospel is not just the door into the Christian life; it is the fuel for the whole journey. We do not grow by trying harder under the law; we grow by rehearsing the grace we have already received, which produces gratitude, and gratitude produces obedience of a different quality entirely (Bridges, 2012). The order of Exodus 20 is the order of the Christian life: rescue, then response, then obedience that is finally free, because it is no longer earning anything.
Read the Scripture the way the Scripture reads itself. When Luke calls the Bereans "of more noble character" than the Thessalonians, that is not an objective report. It is Luke's own evaluation, an inspired authorial aside placed inside the narrative to guide the reader (Acts 17:11). And what does the inspired author commend? Not that they agreed with Paul. That they examined the Scriptures daily to see whether what Paul said was true. Paul was an apostle, the most authoritative teacher imaginable, and the Bereans tested even his words against the Scripture. The Bible carries its own built-in commentary, and here it is commending the very thing a ladder church is afraid of: not blind acceptance, but careful examination. Read that passage the flat way, as a timeless rule, and you will miss that it is not a rule at all. It is a model. It is the reason we can teach our people to weigh a verse in its context without teaching them to distrust the Bible. The Scripture itself models the examination it commends.
What changes when you stop reading the law as a ladder
The last part of this is practical, because theology that doesn't land in a room changes nothing.
For preachers: the law belongs after the rescue in your sermons too. Preach grace first and imperatives second, and the imperatives stop sounding like threats and start sounding like gratitude. The order of Exodus 20 is the order of every faithful sermon.
For Bible study leaders: context before application. When someone asks what a law means for us, the first answer is what it meant for Israel. That single discipline would transform our Bible studies more than any curriculum change. It is the difference between reading the text and using the text. It is also, frankly, the difference between teaching people to think and teaching people to quote. We need people who can weigh a verse in its context, because the world our children live in is full of fluent, confident voices quoting Scripture for their own purposes. A church that only knows how to string verses together is a church that can be led anywhere.
For parents: stop making the faith a list your children are graded on. The children who left our churches did not all leave for the same reason, and the research on the dechurched is careful to say so (Davis and Graham, 2023). But David Kinnaman's studies of young people who leave found something our ladder churches should hear: many did not reject the faith because the bar was too high. They rejected a faith they had never been given a reason to want, a faith of rules without a story, obligations without a rescue (Kinnaman, 2011). Helen Lee named this exodus in the Chinese church thirty years ago, in an essay that is still the clearest short account of how a second generation slips out the back door (Lee, 1996). The law kept looks like a debt. Grace lived out looks like a life someone might actually want.
For elders and pastors: name the difference out loud, patiently, again and again. We are not asking our people to keep the law so that God will accept them. God has already accepted them, and the law is a gift for people who are already free.
Last spring, I gave my Wednesday morning friend an answer that was true but useless. I would give it differently now. Keeping the law was never the way in. The rescue came first. The law came after, a gift for the rescued, a portrait of the God who carried them out. And the way we are identified has never changed: faith. Abraham believed. We believe. The same mercy, the same way in, the same God.
May our churches learn to say it the way the Scripture says it. Not "the law must be kept." But "the grace must be lived out."
References
Bridges, J. (2012). The Transforming Power of the Gospel. Colorado Springs: NavPress.
ChinaSource. (2023). Being Chinese, staying Christian in Europe. https://www.chinasource.org/articles/being-chinese-staying-christian-in-europe/
Davis, J., and Graham, M. (2023). The Great Dechurching: Who's Leaving, Why Are They Going, and What Will It Take to Bring Them Back? Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
Goldingay, J. (2003). Israel's Gospel (Old Testament Theology, vol. 1). Downers Grove: IVP Academic.
Greidanus, S. (1999). Preaching Christ from the Old Testament: A Contemporary Hermeneutical Method. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.
Kinnaman, D. (2011). You Lost Me: Why Young Christians Are Leaving Church and Rethinking Faith. Grand Rapids: Baker.
Lee, H. (1996). Silent Exodus. Christianity Today 40, no. 12 (August 12, 1996).
Miller, P. D. (2009). The Ten Commandments. Louisville: Westminster John Knox.
Way, K. (2026). How were people saved in the Old Testament? In "That's a Great Question." Talbot Magazine, Summer 2026. (Print; digital copy in the author's research library.)
Wright, C. J. H. (2004). Old Testament Ethics for the People of God. Downers Grove: IVP Academic.
Wu, C. W. (2025a). 「以經解經」論麥克阿瑟的釋經 [On MacArthur's "using Scripture to interpret Scripture" exegesis]. 胡志偉牧師網誌. https://chiwaiwu.wordpress.com/2025/07/17/%E3%80%8C%E4%BB%A5%E7%B6%93%E8%A7%A3%E7%B6%93%E3%80%8D%E8%AB%96%E9%BA%A5%E5%85%8B%E9%98%BF%E7%91%9F%E7%9A%84%E9%87%8B%E7%B6%93/
Wu, C. W. (2025b). 華人教會揮之不去的「基要主義」之二:從俗世分離出來 [The lingering fundamentalism of Chinese churches, part 2: Separation from the world]. 胡志偉牧師網誌. https://chiwaiwu.wordpress.com/2025/01/04/%e8%8f%af%e4%ba%ba%e6%95%99%e6%9c%83%e6%8f%ae%e4%b9%8b%e4%b8%8d%e5%8e%bb%e7%9a%84%e3%80%8c%e5%9f%ba%e8%a6%81%e4%b8%bb%e7%be%a9%e3%80%8d%e4%b9%8b%e4%ba%8c%ef%bc%9a%e5%be%9e%e4%bf%97%e4%b8%96%e5%88%86/
Yang, F. (1999). Chinese Christians in America: Conversion, Assimilation, and Adhesive Identities. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.

Comments
Post a Comment