Are There Enough 1.5-Gen Pastors to Answer the Call?
I want to give both halves of that their due, because most of the writing I've seen does only one: it catalogues the exodus, or it preaches a hopeful sermon about calling. The deficit is real, but it is not a mystery, and it is not irreversible. It is the product of specific failures, and specific failures have specific fixes. So this post moves from the data to the rebuilding, and gives the second half at least as much weight as the first.
I want to give both halves of that their due, because most of the writing I've seen does only one: it catalogues the exodus, or it preaches a hopeful sermon about calling. The deficit is real, but it is not a mystery, and it is not irreversible. It is the product of specific failures, and specific failures have specific fixes. So this post moves from the data to the rebuilding, and gives the second half at least as much weight as the first.
The problem, in numbers
The most significant recent data comes from the Innovative Space for Asian American Christianity (ISAAC), whose National Survey of Asian American Congregational Practices ran its pilot phase from 2022 to 2024 across 800 Asian American English-language faith communities (ISAAC, n.d.). The findings are the first hard picture of a population that has been chronically under-researched, and they are sobering.
About 35% of Asian American congregations reported having no one under 30 on their ruling board or equivalent governing body — more than double the 17% figure among non-Asian congregations in the same survey (Cheng-Tozun, 2024; Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024). This is not absence from church life; young adults are everywhere in worship teams, children's ministry, tech, and hospitality. The problem is authority. They are welcome to help execute ministry, and excluded from defining its future. And you cannot form a pastor through observation alone. Vocation develops when a person receives responsibility, theological conversation, real feedback, mentoring, and room to make mistakes. A church that uses young adults as free labor while never trusting them to shape ministry is retaining helpers and losing pastors in the same motion. Some may have the title of pastor, but not the real authorities to make changes.
The broader American context makes it harder. Lifeway Research found that 66% of young adults who attended a Protestant church regularly as teenagers dropped out for at least a year between ages 18 and 22 (Molintas, 2021). For Korean American churches the pattern has been starker: the 2011–2012 National Korean American Church Survey found 82.3% of second-generation Korean Americans left immigrant churches after high school, and 45.7% left Christianity entirely (Oh, 2012, as cited in Lee, n.d.). Those figures should be read carefully — "Asian American" is not one ethnicity or one history — but they point to a pipeline constrained long before seminary applications are submitted.
The gender numbers compound it. ISAAC found that 66% of Asian American congregations allowed women to preach in the main service, versus 85% of non-Asian congregations, and only 56% allowed women to serve as head clergy, versus 79% (Huska, 2024). Thirty-two percent did not allow women to teach alone with adult men, nearly double the non-Asian rate (Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024). And men and women disagree about why: 43% of men attributed fewer women in leadership to biblical beliefs, while only 23% of women agreed; women named the overrepresentation of men and work-life balance instead (Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024).
Whatever your convictions on ordination, a church that keeps half its potential leaders doubting whether their gifts will be trusted has cut its own future. The practical message many young Asian American women have received is that ministry welcomes their labor but not their calling.
The most significant recent data comes from the Innovative Space for Asian American Christianity (ISAAC), whose National Survey of Asian American Congregational Practices ran its pilot phase from 2022 to 2024 across 800 Asian American English-language faith communities (ISAAC, n.d.). The findings are the first hard picture of a population that has been chronically under-researched, and they are sobering.
About 35% of Asian American congregations reported having no one under 30 on their ruling board or equivalent governing body — more than double the 17% figure among non-Asian congregations in the same survey (Cheng-Tozun, 2024; Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024). This is not absence from church life; young adults are everywhere in worship teams, children's ministry, tech, and hospitality. The problem is authority. They are welcome to help execute ministry, and excluded from defining its future. And you cannot form a pastor through observation alone. Vocation develops when a person receives responsibility, theological conversation, real feedback, mentoring, and room to make mistakes. A church that uses young adults as free labor while never trusting them to shape ministry is retaining helpers and losing pastors in the same motion. Some may have the title of pastor, but not the real authorities to make changes.
The broader American context makes it harder. Lifeway Research found that 66% of young adults who attended a Protestant church regularly as teenagers dropped out for at least a year between ages 18 and 22 (Molintas, 2021). For Korean American churches the pattern has been starker: the 2011–2012 National Korean American Church Survey found 82.3% of second-generation Korean Americans left immigrant churches after high school, and 45.7% left Christianity entirely (Oh, 2012, as cited in Lee, n.d.). Those figures should be read carefully — "Asian American" is not one ethnicity or one history — but they point to a pipeline constrained long before seminary applications are submitted.
The gender numbers compound it. ISAAC found that 66% of Asian American congregations allowed women to preach in the main service, versus 85% of non-Asian congregations, and only 56% allowed women to serve as head clergy, versus 79% (Huska, 2024). Thirty-two percent did not allow women to teach alone with adult men, nearly double the non-Asian rate (Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024). And men and women disagree about why: 43% of men attributed fewer women in leadership to biblical beliefs, while only 23% of women agreed; women named the overrepresentation of men and work-life balance instead (Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024).
Whatever your convictions on ordination, a church that keeps half its potential leaders doubting whether their gifts will be trusted has cut its own future. The practical message many young Asian American women have received is that ministry welcomes their labor but not their calling.
Why the called hesitate
Christianity Today's reporting on ISAAC named the reasons young Asian Americans resist pastoral ministry: immigrant parents' pressure toward financial success, more attractive opportunities in the nonprofit and for-profit sectors, restrictions on women's leadership, and a mismatch between Gen Z's desire for sustainable rhythms and churches' expectation of near-total availability from staff (Cheng-Tozun, 2024). Those are not selfishness; they are accurate readings of institutional signals.
Parental pressure is less a flaw to fix than a love to redirect. In immigrant families, achievement is bound to sacrifice, honor, filial duty, and survival. The Fuller Youth Institute's Mike Park describes an emotional environment where a child's performance gets tangled up with family honor and self-worth — the "Tiger Mother" image is a caricature, but it points to something real (Park, 2016). A call to ministry in that context can look financially irrational, socially unintelligible, or even ungrateful: "Why do you need seminary debt for a job that pays so little?"
The 24/7 expectation is the second signal. Many Asian American churches still assume the pastor is endlessly available — preacher, counselor, administrator, translator, spiritual parent — and treat family boundaries or protected rest as selfishness (Cheng-Tozun, 2024). Young adults are not rejecting hard work. They are rejecting what they can see is unsustainable, and they are right to.
Christianity Today's reporting on ISAAC named the reasons young Asian Americans resist pastoral ministry: immigrant parents' pressure toward financial success, more attractive opportunities in the nonprofit and for-profit sectors, restrictions on women's leadership, and a mismatch between Gen Z's desire for sustainable rhythms and churches' expectation of near-total availability from staff (Cheng-Tozun, 2024). Those are not selfishness; they are accurate readings of institutional signals.
Parental pressure is less a flaw to fix than a love to redirect. In immigrant families, achievement is bound to sacrifice, honor, filial duty, and survival. The Fuller Youth Institute's Mike Park describes an emotional environment where a child's performance gets tangled up with family honor and self-worth — the "Tiger Mother" image is a caricature, but it points to something real (Park, 2016). A call to ministry in that context can look financially irrational, socially unintelligible, or even ungrateful: "Why do you need seminary debt for a job that pays so little?"
The 24/7 expectation is the second signal. Many Asian American churches still assume the pastor is endlessly available — preacher, counselor, administrator, translator, spiritual parent — and treat family boundaries or protected rest as selfishness (Cheng-Tozun, 2024). Young adults are not rejecting hard work. They are rejecting what they can see is unsustainable, and they are right to.
Why 1.5-generation leaders matter
The 1.5-generation pastor is not simply bilingual. He or she understands why a first-generation parent reads financial security as moral responsibility rather than materialism, and why an English-speaking young adult experiences certain church practices as controlling or opaque. These leaders can hold immigrant sacrifice and the next generation's hunger for authenticity in one hand without collapsing either. The Princeton Theological Seminary Center for Asian American Christianity documents how racialization presses on Asian American families across domestic violence, mental health, and vocational decisions (Center for Asian American Christianity, 2024). Someone who can name what no single side can easily articulate is genuinely valuable.
But there is a temptation here, and I've watched it enough to name it: churches romanticize the 1.5-generation pastor as a magical bridge, then dump impossible expectations on one person and call it faithfulness. No pastor carries all of that alone. The goal is not to find one perfect bridge. The goal is a church where bridges are normal.
The 1.5-generation pastor is not simply bilingual. He or she understands why a first-generation parent reads financial security as moral responsibility rather than materialism, and why an English-speaking young adult experiences certain church practices as controlling or opaque. These leaders can hold immigrant sacrifice and the next generation's hunger for authenticity in one hand without collapsing either. The Princeton Theological Seminary Center for Asian American Christianity documents how racialization presses on Asian American families across domestic violence, mental health, and vocational decisions (Center for Asian American Christianity, 2024). Someone who can name what no single side can easily articulate is genuinely valuable.
But there is a temptation here, and I've watched it enough to name it: churches romanticize the 1.5-generation pastor as a magical bridge, then dump impossible expectations on one person and call it faithfulness. No pastor carries all of that alone. The goal is not to find one perfect bridge. The goal is a church where bridges are normal.
Rebuilding the pipeline: what actually works
Now the part that usually doesn't get said. The pipeline cannot be fixed by one inspirational sermon on calling, and it cannot start at seminary — by then too many potential leaders have already concluded that ministry is financially impossible, culturally unsafe, or personally unsustainable. It has to be rebuilt down at the level of structure and habit. Here are the interventions I believe in, and the tools I have on my own shelf for them.
1. Put a real seat at the table, and give it power
ISAAC's 35%-without-young-leaders number is the cheapest problem to fix and the most neglected (Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024). Not a token seat — a real one with voice in budgets, staffing, and priorities. Check your bylaws before assuming you need an amendment; many churches already permit advisory or ex-officio positions that simply sit empty. A church that only trusts a 27-year-old to run slides should not be surprised the person never imagines being a pastor. Reports from the advisory committee or person without real consideration is just lip service. Count how many times the recommendations are being enacted tells the story.
2. Redesign how boards actually share power
This is where I keep coming back to a book that's been on my shelf for years: Eric Law's The Wolf Shall Dwell with the Lamb (Law, 1993). Law is a Chinese American Episcopal priest who spent years working in multicultural congregations, and his central observation is that the default ways we run meetings are not culturally neutral. The volunteer method, the "whoever speaks loudest controls the floor" method, the deference-to-rank method — each silently favors some voices and silences others. His answer is a deceptively simple practice called Mutual Invitation: the leader shares first, then explicitly invites one specific person to share; that person speaks and then has the right to invite the next, with the option to pass. In his account, a bishop had to wait to be invited by a support staff member before he spoke — an exercise, as Law puts it, of the "miracle of the ear" (Law, 1993).
I will not pretend a meeting technique changes a congregation's theology. But the reason the ISAAC numbers barely move is often that even when a church decides "yes, more young leaders," the actual room they step into is still run exactly the way it has always been run — and they leave. Mutual Invitation is a concrete, teachable way to make a governing space genuinely shared rather than politely tolerant. That is the difference between offering young people a seat and actually sharing power with them.
3. Make women's pathways visible and real
Here I want to be careful not to flatten a genuine theological debate. But the data forces a question even a complementarian church can ask: are women receiving theological education, mentoring, and public trust appropriate to the congregation's convictions — and are the restrictions communicated honestly and pastorally, or enforced by default? Young Lee Hertig, ISAAC's executive director, is blunt that what some churches call "biblical" is male-filtered, and asks who is doing the hermeneutics (Hertig, as cited in Huska, 2024).
ISAAC's PastoraLab is the most constructive response I know. Launched in 2021 through a Lilly Endowment Thriving in Ministry grant, it has convened more than 70 participants in leadership development, prophetic preaching workshops, and community-building retreats for Asian American women ministers; an external evaluation found increased agency, confidence, and adaptive leadership capacity among participants (Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 2024). A calling needs a community of discernment, not just private determination. At minimum, every church should track who gets to teach, lead, mentor, attend conferences, and enter paid roles. What is not measured is easily ignored.
4. Let the second generation build what they're building
The most hopeful research I have found on this sits on my shelf, and it flips the usual despair. Sharon Kim's A Faith of Our Own studied second-generation Korean American churches who are not trying to reproduce either the immigrant church or a white evangelical church; they are deliberately carving out what she calls a "hybrid third space." Kim shows these leaders are cautious, deliberate, and inventive — they want the worship and organization of American evangelicalism but preserve tongsongkido (unison prayer) and the collectivist emphasis of Korean Christianity, and they reject the materialism they see in both worlds (S. Kim, 2010). She calls these churches "spiritual laboratories."
The church that treats this energy as a threat is the church that keeps losing it. The church that blesses it — that commissions teachers, nonprofit leaders, campus ministers, church planters, and bi-vocational pastors as legitimate kingdom callings — turns an exodus into a sending.
Rebecca Kim's earlier study of Korean American campus evangelicals adds the sharpest detail. She found that second-generation students, given a choice among ministries, tend to choose ones where they can get leadership positions and influence, where they are least likely to be marginalized — in effect, they vote with their feet for the room where they can lead (R. Kim, 2006). That is not a comfortable finding for an immigrant church board. It means the young person who leaves is often not leaving the faith; they are leaving a room where they were never going to be allowed to lead.
5. Build a discernment pathway with a shape to it
Every congregation should be able to answer, in specifics, what happens when someone says "I think God may be calling me." The answer "pray about it and talk to the pastor" is not a pathway. A real one has a designated mentor, a six-to-twelve-month process of prayer and reading and a ministry experiment with feedback, exposure to multiple ministry forms (local church, chaplaincy, campus ministry, nonprofit, bi-vocational), honest financial guidance about seminary debt, and a way for parents and elders to be part of the conversation. It is paid internship or residency, not unpaid labor dressed up as development. ISAAC's mentoring and internship work models this exactly (ISAAC, n.d.).
6. Treat parents as partners and redesign the job
Parents are not obstacles; they are the first people who need pastoral care when a child discerns a call. A congregation can host intergenerational forums on vocation and faithful work, and let parents hear from pastors who entered ministry mid-career or bi-vocationally, so their children's call does not look like a rejection of family sacrifice but a fruit of it. And the compensation question has to be answered honestly: a church that asks a young adult to "trust God" while offering a salary that cannot cover housing, insurance, or debt is not exercising faith, it is exercising irresponsibility (Cheng-Tozun, 2024).
The larger job redesign is where Barna's data lands hardest. Barna found that 54% of pastors disagree that their church significantly prioritizes training and developing the next generation of leaders — up 22% since 2015 — and that 79% agree churches are failing to raise up the next generation. Only 16% of Protestant senior pastors are under 40, and the average pastor is 52 (Barna Group, 2023). That is an aging clergy with an untended pipeline. The fix is structural: realistic job descriptions, protected rest, compensation tied to local cost of living, shared leadership instead of one heroic pastor, a board accountable for the pastor's well-being as well as performance. Gary McIntosh's One Size Doesn't Fit All is right that a smaller church cannot be governed like a megachurch, and a healthier model has to fit actual size rather than aspiration (McIntosh, 1999).
The call is still there
So here is where I land, and it is genuinely both. There are not enough 1.5-generation pastors if we mean enough produced automatically by the systems we have — those systems are failing to produce them, and quietly discouraging some of the people we need most.
But there are almost certainly more called leaders among us than we recognize. They are the young professional torn between family expectations and a summons they cannot dismiss. They are the college student serving faithfully with no visible future pathway. They are the women discerning pastoral gifts while watching authority go to men by default. They are the nonprofit workers who never rejected the church, only its failure to know how to develop people well.
The pipeline problem is not just a recruitment problem. It is a governance problem, a gender problem, a compensation problem, a discipleship problem, and a trust problem. And none of those are beyond a congregation's capacity to change. Boards can share power — Law shows us how. Congregations can bless the spaces the next generation is already building. Senior pastors can mentor. Parents can learn to bless rather than merely protect. Women can be seen and developed. Pastors can be paid a living wage and given a life. The question before Asian American churches is not simply who will replace our pastors. It is what kind of church we must become so that the people God is calling can answer with freedom, courage, and joy.
If we want enough 1.5-generation pastors to answer the call, we have to become the kind of church that makes answering possible. The tools are on the shelf. The question is whether we'll use them.
References
Barna Group. (2023, August 23). The pastoral succession crisis is only getting more complicated. https://www.barna.com/research/pastoral-succession/
Center for Asian American Christianity. (2024). Areas of theological focus. Princeton Theological Seminary. https://ptsem.edu/academics/centers/center-for-asian-american-christianity/caac-areas-of-focus/
Cheng-Tozun, D. (2024, July 30). In Asian American churches, generational differences deter young leaders. Christianity Today. https://www.christianitytoday.com/2024/07/asian-american-pastors-generations-church-survey-isaac-chri/
Huska, L. (2024, August 7). Fewer chances for women to preach and pastor at Asian American churches, new survey shows. The Christian Century. https://www.christiancentury.org/news/fewer-chances-women-preach-and-pastor-asian-american-churches-new-survey-shows
Innovative Space for Asian American Christianity. (n.d.). PastoraLab research project. Retrieved September 29, 2026, from https://www.isaacweb.org/research-project
Kim, R. Y. (2006). God's new whiz kids? Korean American evangelicals on campus. New York University Press.
Kim, S. (2010). A faith of our own: Second-generation spirituality in Korean American churches. Rutgers University Press.
Law, E. H. F. (1993). The wolf shall dwell with the lamb: A spirituality for leadership in a multicultural community. Chalice Press.
Lee, H. A. (n.d.). The effects of intergenerational ministry on spiritual maturity among Korean American young adults who participated in the ministry during adolescence. Talbot School of Theology. https://www.aymeducators.org/wp-content/uploads/zThe-Effects-of-Intergenerational-Ministry-on-Spiritual-Maturity-Among-Korean-American-Young-Adults.pdf
McIntosh, G. L. (1999). One size doesn't fit all: Bringing out the best in any size church. Fleming H. Revell.
Molintas, H. (2021, September 17). Solving the "silent exodus" from churches. Lifeway Research. https://research.lifeway.com/2021/09/17/solving-the-silent-exodus-from-churches/
Oh, S. J. (2012). [National Korean American Church Survey], as cited in Lee (n.d.).
Park, M. (2016, June 21). Rediscovering grace: Challenges and opportunities in Asian American youth ministry. Fuller Youth Institute. https://fulleryouthinstitute.org/blog/opportunities-challenges-in-asian-american-youth-ministry
Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.). (2024, June 26). Report: Asian American women have fewer church leadership opportunities. https://pcusa.org/news-storytelling/news/2024/6/26/report-asian-american-women-have-fewer-church-leadership-opportunities

Comments
Post a Comment