Gray Temples, Empty Pews: What Does Faithfulness Look Like Now?


A reflection by a 1.5 gen Chinese-American pastor | Part 2 of 3

← Back to Part 1 — From Sojourners to Saints: The Making of the Chinese Immigrant Church


I walk into the sanctuary on a Sunday morning, and I count.

Not as a consultant; I left that life. I count as a pastor, and what I count breaks my heart a little each week. The gray heads outnumber the dark ones. The people who built this church, who gave sacrificially to buy this building, who drove the same freeway off-ramp every Sunday for decades, are here. Their children, mostly, are not.

This reality is faced by many Chinese immigrant churches across North America. We must honestly acknowledge it before speaking truthfully into it. Part 1 outlined their origins: the laoqiao and xinqiao waves, campus Bible studies evolving into congregations, the Triplex and Townhouse models, and the HUP-shaped mission that effectively reached new arrivals but lost its own children. Now, we need to examine what this history has created: a church at a critical generational crossroads, embodying deep faithfulness while facing an uncertain future reflected in its financial reports.

Before we can talk about what to do, we need to do something harder: tell the truth about why we are here. The forces that produced this moment are not simply demographic or historical. They are theological. And until we reckon with the theology we inherited, we will keep treating symptoms while the underlying disease goes unexamined.


The Demographic Picture We Can No Longer Avoid

Rev. Dr. Chi Wai Wu, writing for ChinaSource, describes the current state of most Chinese immigrant churches as marked by four defining characteristics: high mobility, high diversity, high competition, and low sustainability, what he calls the "Three Highs and One Low" phenomenon (Wu, 2024). Most Chinese pastors in the United States, Canada, Australia, and the UK will recognize this pattern without needing a study to confirm it.

High mobility means the population these churches were built to serve keeps moving: graduates relocate for careers, young families move for school districts, and elderly members return to Asia to be near their own children. High diversity means newer arrivals, including mainland Chinese professionals, Hong Kong BNO visa holders, and Southeast Asian diaspora communities, carry cultural expectations that existing Taiwanese- or Cantonese-dominated congregations were never designed to accommodate. High competition means urban centers with significant Chinese populations now host dozens of congregations competing for a shrinking pool of active first-generation churchgoers. And low sustainability means that institutional health depends on a founding generation aging out of peak giving years, with no comparable cohort behind them (Wu, 2024).

The English ministries launched through the 1990s and 2000s were supposed to solve the generational problem. They did not. An estimated 70% to 80% of second-generation adults leave their home churches after high school, with some studies suggesting the figure reaches as high as 90% for post-college young people (Cha, Kang, & Lee, 2006; Lee, 1996; Li, 2020; as cited in Choi, 2023). Helen Lee named this the "Silent Exodus" in 1996, and that exodus has not reversed in the decades since. It has simply been normalized, absorbed into the institutional furniture of churches that now quietly accept their children's departure as an unavoidable consequence of Americanization rather than a diagnostic failure of pastoral vision and ecclesiological structure (Lee, 1996).

What remains in many congregations is a faithful remnant: people who love God and love each other, who have given decades to a community that shaped their families, friendships, and faith. They are not failures. But the institution around them faces a pressure that faithfulness alone cannot resolve. The first step toward addressing it honestly is understanding how the theology these churches taught has shaped the very crisis they are in.


The Theology We Built, And What It Cost Us

Chinese immigrant churches did not arrive at their current crisis by accident. The structures and paradigms that shaped these congregations encoded particular answers to the most important questions any church asks: What does it mean to be faithful? What does fruitfulness look like? What does God honor?

The answers, drawn from a combination of Confucian cultural inheritance and American evangelical church-growth frameworks, formed a coherent but ultimately self-limiting theological vision.

Faithfulness was defined as endurance through suffering. First-generation pastors rightly emphasized perseverance through the hardships of immigrant life as a primary act of devotion. But over time, this framing calcified: the second generation's desires for emotional health, work-life integration, or pastoral accountability became legible within this framework only as "a lack of sacrifice" or insufficient love for God (Kwan, 2016, p. 4; Chiu, 2022, p. 103). The immigrant cross, real and costly, became the only recognized form of discipleship. Every other cross was suspect.

Cultural preservation became a spiritual mandate. Some first-generation leaders developed what one scholar calls the "Returning to Egypt" syndrome: a theology in which retaining Chinese language and culture functions as a sign of spiritual faithfulness, while assimilation is implicitly equated with secularization or "backsliding" (O. Park, 2021, pp. 16, 111). In this framework, the church's calling is not missional but conserving, holding the community together in its original cultural form against the dissolving forces of the host society. It is a theology of the ark, not of the mission.

Success was measured by what could be counted easily. Leaders routinely defined fruitfulness by worship attendance and financial stability within the mother-tongue congregation (Kwan, 2016, p. 15). The continuous influx of new immigrants in major metropolitan areas created what researchers identify as a "false sense of vitality": a church could watch its own children depart in large numbers while still registering numerical growth from the immigrant pipeline, deferring the reckoning that the departure demanded (Kwan, 2016, p. 15; Sohn, 2017, p. 234). The metric system was engineered, whether intentionally or not, to make the Silent Exodus invisible.

Honor was measured by secular achievement, not spiritual formation. Shaped by Confucian norms, the honor of a family, and by extension, the church, was tied to the academic and professional accomplishments of its children (Chao, 2024, p. 307; Gianakakos, 2021, p. 81). A child who became a doctor or engineer was evidence of parental faithfulness. A child who stopped attending church was a private grief but not a pastoral indictment. Departure was framed as an unavoidable consequence of Americanization, a structural inevitability rather than a failure of discipleship (Yuan, 2021, p. 152; Chiu, 2022, p. 116).

The cumulative effect of these frameworks is a church incapable of asking honestly: Did we form disciples, or did we produce high-achieving immigrants who happened to attend Sunday school? David Choi, a second-generation pastor now serving within a Chinese immigrant church, locates the root of the problem precisely: children experienced Christ in these communities not as Lord but as a "moral figure to keep good kids from going bad," a moral technology of Asian culture more than a genuine call to personal faith (Choi, 2023). As Charles Kim of Oriental Mission Church observed, the second generation could no longer "differentiate between Asian culture and Christianity, and then they often develop a hatred of the culture, which they then extend to Christianity" (as cited in Choi, 2023). When Asian culture became available and celebrated elsewhere, without the church, there was no distinctly Christian reason left to attend.


The Ecclesiology That Reinforced It All

This theology of success did not stand alone. It was held in place by an ecclesiology that made it structurally resistant to internal challenge.

Research on Chinese immigrant church governance consistently identifies a high Power Distance Index (PDI): a Confucian inheritance that assigns authority automatically to senior pastors and elders on the basis of age, position, and tenure, rather than through collaborative processes (Li, 2020, p. 80). This creates what researchers call a "clerical" view of the church, with spiritual work and institutional decision-making concentrated in the senior leader while the congregation remains functionally passive (Li, 2020, p. 55).

The consequence for the 1.5 and second generation was structural exclusion dressed in theological language. These young adults, educated, mature in faith, and carrying cross-cultural competencies their parents often lacked, were routinely relegated to what one researcher aptly calls "Youth Group 2.0" status: perpetually viewed as children incapable of leading, which conveniently justified their exclusion from eldership, board roles, and governing decisions (Yuan, 2021, p. 8; Kwan, 2016, p. 15). The English Ministry pastor occupied a structurally untenable position: pastoral responsibility without institutional authority, perpetually negotiating with a first-generation board that controlled the budget, the building, and the church's ultimate direction.

Charles Choe, a second-generation Korean American pastor and church planter of Tapestry LA, described his experience as an EM pastor within a large immigrant church: "There was always this feeling like I was a child. Even though the people I led were adults, it always felt like I was leading children. And I always kind of resented that, and I always struggled with it" (as cited in Choi, 2023). This is not an exceptional experience; it is the normative structural reality of English Ministry leadership across Chinese and Korean immigrant churches (Choi, 2023). Tim Tseng states the consequence plainly: "Unless the first-generation leaders are able to give second-generation pastors the freedom to lead, their young people will not go to these churches" (as cited in Choi, 2023). Robert Goette adds a sobering note about the structural likelihood of change: "In Asian culture, you have a very slow giving over of authority and control to the younger generation. Often, the control resides with the parents until they die" (as cited in Choi, 2023).

When the second generation finally left, many congregations did not undertake honest self-examination. The same shame culture that had prevented honest conversation during the crisis now prevented honest accounting after it. Admitting that the Silent Exodus reflected leadership and discipleship failure, rather than inevitable cultural drift, would cost face. So the narrative of Americanization served its function: it exonerated the institution and placed the weight of departure on the children who left (Kwan, 2016, p. 3; Sohn, 2017, p. 264).


Toward a Theology of Faithful Presence in Decline

The theological tradition has resources for this moment that evangelical Chinese churches have largely left unmined. Accessing them means reading the biblical narrative differently than the growth-church framework permits.

Naomi returns to Bethlehem in famine and grief, telling the townswomen to call her "Mara," bitter, because "the Almighty has dealt very bitterly with me" (Ruth 1:20, ESV). The fruit of that season, the gleaning, the loyalty, the kinsman-redeemer, comes not despite the honesty about loss but through it. Isaiah's remnant theology likewise resists the numerical framework: the seven thousand who had not bowed the knee to Baal were invisible to Elijah's metrics but not to God's. The seven churches of Revelation receive letters ranging from commendation to rebuke to urgent warning; not one is evaluated primarily by its attendance.

Wu (2024) makes a theologically significant proposal for churches in this season: rather than chasing numerical growth as the marker of faithfulness, overseas Chinese churches should reposition themselves around a chaplaincy model, faithfully forming disciples-on-the-move. This is not sowing seed and calling it a harvest. Formation means equipping people for transformed lives, not just feeding them more biblical knowledge to collect, and releasing them well rather than measuring faithfulness by how many stay. A congregation that runs Bible studies for intellectual assent and social belonging, then counts a nodded head or a recited confession as fruit, has confused information transfer with discipleship, and Wu's model gives no cover for that confusion. "Even if one day, a Chinese church has fewer people and closes," Wu writes, "it is not a shameful thing" (Wu, 2024). The church that grasps that its faithfulness is measured by the quality of formation and sending, not by Sunday attendance, will find a freedom the growth paradigm could never offer, but that freedom has to be earned through the slow work of actually forming people, not claimed as an excuse to stop trying.

Daniel Chan, an English-speaking pastor serving within a Chinese immigrant congregation, offers a pastoral counterweight: the right response to institutional imperfection is not reflexive departure but patient, reforming presence, provided the church holds a faithful understanding of the gospel and a genuine commitment to preaching God's Word (Chan, 2020). "While change in immigrant churches can be slow, it's not impossible," Chan writes. "Don't equate patience with compromise" (Chan, 2020). Second-generation leaders who stay and push patiently for real structural change may be exactly the agents of slow institutional transformation these congregations need, and part of that reform is refusing to let "we had Bible study" stand in for "we made disciples."


What Fruitfulness Actually Looks Like Now

Once we have done the harder work of theological honesty, fruitfulness can be described in terms that are both biblically grounded and contextually realistic for the aging Chinese immigrant congregation.

Deep discipleship over broad programming. A congregation of sixty well-discipled, mutually caring believers who know how to suffer together, pray together, and serve their neighborhood is not a failure (Cha, Kang, & Lee, 2006). It is the body of Christ functioning as designed, in a form that produces no church-growth conference keynote but that matters to the God who counts differently than we do. The shift from program multiplication to relational depth is not a concession to decline; it is the recovery of something lost when growth became the primary metric.

Releasing what was built. The most missionally significant act available to a declining congregation may be to release its assets, including the building, young families, and financial reserves, to strengthen or plant a new congregation rather than sustaining an institutional form that no longer serves the full body. Wu (2024) frames this as the church's participation in the diaspora's mobility itself: the goal is to equip immigrant congregations to become "people on the move" rather than anchors that resist movement. The first generation that holds what it has built with open hands participates in the logic of John 12:24, the grain of wheat that bears fruit precisely by falling.

Genuine pastoral presence with the aging. Liou and Shenk (2016) document what Chinese immigrant church pastors already know: the church functions as the primary, sometimes the only, sustained community of care for Chinese adults over 65, and yet emotional support within those communities is frequently insufficient to the actual needs of older members. Pastoring this population faithfully means attending theologically to aging, physical decline, death, and resurrection, subjects that Chinese cultural norms around face have long made nearly impossible to address openly in immigrant church contexts. These are the people who carried the gospel through their own displacement and built the communities in which most of us first encountered Jesus. They deserve a pastor willing to sit with them in the dark, not merely celebrate them at anniversary banquets.

Genuine structural succession, not symbolic transition. For congregations where succession remains possible, where 1.5 or second-generation leaders are present and willing, the research is unambiguous about what must change. Structural power must be transferred, not just the pastoral title (Yuan, 2021, p. 152). Governing boards must include English-speaking leaders with genuine decision-making authority, not advisory roles (Chiu, 2022, p. 116). Chan's model, renaming the English congregation, establishing its own membership process, and ordaining English-speaking elders after nearly a decade of patient institutional work, offers a concrete if slow path forward (Chan, 2020). It is not glamorous. It requires the first generation to believe, at the level of actual governance rather than mere sentiment, that the English-speaking body is a full partner in the church's mission.


The Question Underneath All the Questions

The Chinese immigrant church in its present form is not outside the scope of God's care or purposes. It is at a moment that requires a different kind of pastoral leadership than the one that built it. The builder's virtues, vision, institutional creativity, the ability to inspire new arrivals, and the willingness to sacrifice for the community gave us what we have. What this season asks of us are different virtues: the wisdom to grieve honestly, the courage to name what is true, the tenderness to pastor people through endings, and the faith to believe that the communities being formed and sent in this season will bear fruit that outlasts the institutions from which they emerge.

The question underneath all the questions is this: Whose church is this? If it belongs to the first generation, to the people who built it, who named it, who gave their resources and their years to it, then its decline is a tragedy, and faithfulness is what you do while a tragedy unfolds. But if it belongs to God, if it was always a vessel for a mission larger than the community that carried it, then its transformation, even its ending, is not a tragedy. It is the continuation of the same story that began when a few Chinese students opened their Bibles in a university basement and, without planning to, became a church.


Continue reading: Part 3 — The Necessary Disruption: Transformation and the Chinese Immigrant Church


Sources

  • Cha, P., Kang, S. S., & Lee, H. (Eds.). (2006). Growing healthy Asian American churches: Ministry insights from groundbreaking congregations. InterVarsity Press.
  • Chan, D. (2020, June 22). Helping second-generation immigrants love the immigrant church. 9Marks. https://www.9marks.org/article/helping-second-generation-immigrants-love-the-immigrant-church/
  • Chao, S. N. (2024). Differences in servant leadership preference in Chinese heritage churches by generation and culture (PhD dissertation, Biola University).
  • Chiu, C. (2022). Time for a new model: The case for English Ministry partner churches for the Chinese immigrant church in the USA (Doctoral project, Biola University).
  • Choi, D. (2023). Becoming an Asian-American church. Mere Orthodoxy. https://mereorthodoxy.com/becoming-an-asian-american-church/
  • Gianakakos, T. (2021). Challenges related to the transmission of faith to the second generation in a small suburban Cantonese Chinese church (Doctoral project, Biola University).
  • Kwan, K. T. N. (2016). Building a two-generational Chinese immigrant church for world mission (Doctoral project, Biola University).
  • Lee, H. (1996, August 12). Silent exodus. Christianity Today, 40(9), 50–53.
  • Li, A. (2020). An analysis of the cultural and leadership differences among leaders in the Chinese immigrant church in America (Doctoral project, Biola University).
  • Liou, C.-L., & Shenk, D. (2016). A case study of exploring older Chinese immigrants' social support within a Chinese church community in the United States. Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology, 31(3), 293–309. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10823-016-9292-2
  • O. Park (2021). Are we returning to Egypt? A question for Korean immigrant churches (Doctoral project, Biola University).
  • Sohn, E. (2017). Attitudes of Asian American Christians towards the ethnic churches they left (Doctoral project, Alliance Theological Seminary).
  • Wu, C. W. (2024, June 17). The transformation of overseas Chinese churches: "Three highs and one low." ChinaSource. https://www.chinasource.org/articles/the-transformation-of-overseas-chinese-churches-three-highs-and-one-low/
  • Yang, F. (1999). Chinese Christians in America: Conversion, assimilation, and adhesive identities. Pennsylvania State University Press.
  • Yuan, D. (2021). A historical and cross-cultural analysis of the Home of Christ Church in Cupertino: Identifying obstacles for potential English eldership (Doctoral project, Biola University).

Comments

  1. Another very well thought out post. I can identify in so many ways since I've experienced/attended a number of Chinese Immigrant Churches that have grown to the point of performing multiple and successful church plants as well as those that have declined and are struggling to survive. Can I pinpoint exactly what made some flourish vs others fail? Maybe and maybe not. Some of what you've written here are definite factors such as not giving enough authority to the English ministry leaders and not having a pastor that's willing to stay for the long haul and spend the time building relationships with the people who make up the church. Nevertheless, I whole heartedly agree with you that in the end the church belongs to God. Whatever that has transpired should never been seen as a tragedy. Because in the end, souls have been saved, God's people has been transformed, and all His promises fulfilled of never leaving us or forsaking us.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! Yes, Jesus says, 'On this rock I will build my church.' The trap is that many church leaders treat governance and models as 'sacred cows'—nearly unchangeable. I resonate with Dr. Enoch Wan's diaspora missiology: the church, like each of us, is on a mission, and seasons change. The word 'immigrant' itself implies non-permanence, reminding the church to keep planning for its next season. My next post will explore what a newly established church can do—I hope you'll check it out.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

From Sojourners to Saints: The Making of the Chinese Immigrant Church

The Necessary Disruption: Transformation and the Chinese Immigrant Church